Answer: A
Protonation of C-1 (the terminal CHX2 next to the methyl-bearing carbon) gives the tertiary allylic cation (CHX3)X2CX+−CH=CHX2, more stable than the secondary allylic cation from protonation at C-4. Its positive charge is larger at the tertiary carbon, so kinetic attack there gives the 1,2-adduct (CHX3)X2CCl−CH=CHX2. The 1,4-adduct 1-chloro-3-methylbut-2-ene is the thermodynamic product.