Answer: A, D
A locked perpendicular biphenyl is chiral (atropisomerism) only if neither ring has a mirror plane containing the inter-ring axis, i.e. each ring must carry two different ortho groups. P has NOX2 and COOH on each ring (6,6-dinitrobiphenyl-2,2-dicarboxylic acid): chiral. S has CHX3 and Cl on each ring: chiral. Q has two CHX3 on each ring, so the plane of either ring is a mirror plane: achiral. R has one ring with CHX3 and NOX2 but the other ring with two CHX3; the plane of the first ring reflects the second ring onto itself, so R is achiral.