Answer: A, B, C
In the gas phase the polarisability of larger alkyl groups stabilises the alkoxide, so tert-butyl alcohol is more acidic (A). In water, the small methoxide is better solvated, so methanol is more acidic (B), and this solvation explains the reversal (C). In the gas phase the observed order is opposite to that predicted from the +I effect alone, so (D) is wrong.