Answer: D
The benzylic tertiary cation CHX3−CX+(Ph)X− is the more stable one. A methyl shift from the neighbouring C(CHX3)X2OH gives CHX3CO−C(CHX3)X2Ph. If the other cation formed, phenyl migration would give the same ketone, so 3-methyl-3-phenylbutan-2-one is obtained either way.